Quick Design #3
One of the most persuasive conversations I’ve heard recently was Dice Exploder’s episode on Traits (Pendragon). I really love the idea of a set of stats that act as role play prompts.

An oversimplified rundown of Pendragon’s mechanic, is that it’s a list of 13 emotional dichotomies. The 26 individual traits have their own individual score, but the sum of each pair must equal 20. For example:
| Forgiving 13 | Vengeful 7 |
When the situation calls for it, you pick a pair then select one to roll under. If you attempt to be Vengeful and roll above 7, then you must attempt to be Forgiving. If you fail the second roll by rolling over 13, then you may choose either emotional response. This is specifically not a skill check or an action roll. These are role play prompts
| Valorous 4 | Cowardly 16 |
If one trait is 16 or higher, you must attempt that emotional response first, because your character is famously known for that trait.
| Chaste 20 | Lustful 0 |
If one trait has reached 20, you must act in that manner at all times because they are exalted in that trait.
Now I don’t know enough about Pendragon to explain how exactly traits increase, but I do know that when one increases it proportionally decreases its paired opposition. This tug of war system reminds me of All Outta Bubblegum (2001), Lasers & Feelings (2013), and Honey Heist (2017)
But, how can I steal adapt this trait mechanic?
I’m a big fan of role play prompts being baked into game design. Halloween 2025 I released Prop Master which is a tabletop rpg where you pretend you are live-action role playing a D&D game on a stage. It treats items as props, and the HP system are role play prompts based off a pain scale (not everyone has held a real sword, let alone been really stabbed—but I’m willing to bet most people who play TTRPGs have pretended to have a “sword fight” with their friends using sticks, and accidentally got hurt doing so)
I still plan on updating Prop Master at some point, but I released a spiritual successor of sorts for the one page rpg jam 2026. AWNER which stands for Adventurers Wanted, No Experience Required, uses a similar pain system but introduces the concept of “Hats.” In this game, I took common character classes and turned them into a combination of “thinking caps” and character stats

Now, on to the “quick design” portion of this post, in which I design a mechanic in browser as I write the blog post, while trying not to overthink it
What If Your Character’s Selected Their Own Class?
Like parents imagining the future for their children, players may have an idea of which class they what their character to be, but maybe player characters have a mind of their own!
There might be something to this idea that I should revisit in the future, but I wrote up a whole mechanic and it just wasn’t working like I wanted it to… F*** it. Scrap the role play prompts. Let’s make it into a resolution mechanic!

Pencildragon
a quickly designed ttrpg
DIY & dragons has a fantastic post about underlying ability scores that I’ve attempted to use in a game once before. In retrospect, my execution wasn’t the best—but I’m going to take another whack at it!
To summarize, she lays out three different dichotomies…
🟦 PHYSICAL vs MENTAL
🟨 FORCE vs GRACE
🟥 ATTACK vs DEFENSE
…then she listed the eight underlying abilities using a combination of possibilities…
| 🟦 | + | 🟨 | + | 🟥 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1. | Physical | + | Force | + | Attack |
| 2. | Physical | + | Grace | + | Attack |
| 3. | Physical | + | Force | + | Defense |
| 4. | Physical | + | Grace | + | Defense |
| 5. | Mental | + | Force | + | Attack |
| 6. | Mental | + | Grace | + | Attack |
| 7. | Mental | + | Force | + | Defense |
| 8. | Mental | + | Grace | + | Defense |
If you want an example for each, please check out her blog post.
First, I’m going to switch Pendragon’s trait mechanic from a roll under, to a roll over. DIY & dragon’s three dichotomies will get turned into six stats with difficulty scores ranging from 0-4, but beginning with a difficulty score of 2. When one skill increases in difficulty, its opposite decreases in difficulty. The most difficulty a combination can be is 12 (4+4+4), so instead of a D20 we will use a D12.
⏳ Example Of Play
The quickest way to pitch this resolution mechanic is to provide an example of play, so here are a few turns
TURN ONE: "You encounter a locked door…"
| PHYSICAL | 🔵🔵⚪️⚪️ |
| MENTAL | 🔵🔵⚪️⚪️ |
| FORCE | 🟡🟡⚪️⚪️ |
| GRACE | 🟡🟡⚪️⚪️ |
| ATTACK | 🔴🔴⚪️⚪️ |
| DEFENSE | 🔴🔴⚪️⚪️ |
"…you attempt to pick the lock with some scrap wire…"
| Physical | Grace | Attack | TN | |||
| 🔵🔵 | + | 🟡🟡 | + | 🔴🔴 | = | 6 |
"…you roll your D12, hoping to get equal to or above the target number of 6…"
"…and you fail with a roll of 4. Increase the difficulty of all three stats by one, taking a difficulty point from its opposite."
| PHYSICAL | 🔵🔵🔵⚪️ |
| MENTAL | 🔵✖️⚪️⚪️ |
| FORCE | 🟡✖️⚪️⚪️ |
| GRACE | 🟡🟡🟡⚪️ |
| ATTACK | 🔴🔴🔴⚪️ |
| DEFENSE | 🔴✖️⚪️⚪️ |
TURN TWO: "The door remains locked…"
| PHYSICAL | 🔵🔵🔵⚪️ |
| MENTAL | 🔵⚪️⚪️⚪️ |
| FORCE | 🟡⚪️⚪️⚪️ |
| GRACE | 🟡🟡🟡⚪️ |
| ATTACK | 🔴🔴🔴⚪️ |
| DEFENSE | 🔴⚪️⚪️⚪️ |
"…in frustration, you attempt to break the door down with a kick…"
| Physical | Force | Attack | TN | |||
| 🔵🔵🔵 | + | 🟡 | + | 🔴🔴🔴 | = | 7 |
"…you roll your D12, hoping to get equal to or above the target number of 7…"
"…and you fail with a roll of 2. Increase the difficulty of all three stats by one, taking a difficulty point from its opposite."
| PHYSICAL | 🔵🔵🔵🔵 |
| MENTAL | ✖️⚪️⚪️⚪️ |
| FORCE | 🟡🟡⚪️⚪️ |
| GRACE | 🟡🟡✖️⚪️ |
| ATTACK | 🔴🔴🔴🔴 |
| DEFENSE | ✖️⚪️⚪️⚪️ |
TURN THREE: "The door barely budged with your assault…"
| PHYSICAL | 🔵🔵🔵🔵 |
| MENTAL | ⚪️⚪️⚪️⚪️ |
| FORCE | 🟡🟡⚪️⚪️ |
| GRACE | 🟡🟡⚪️⚪️ |
| ATTACK | 🔴🔴🔴🔴 |
| DEFENSE | ⚪️⚪️⚪️⚪️ |
"…you take a moment to collect yourself and hear the noise of someone cowering on the other side of the door. With a deep breath, you take a chance and command them to open the door for you…"
| Mental | Force | Attack | TN | |||
| + | 🟡🟡 | + | 🔴🔴🔴🔴 | = | 6 |
"…you roll your D12, hoping to get equal to or above the target number of 6…"
"…and you succeed with a roll of 7! Decrease the difficulty of all three stats by one, giving each stat’s difficulty point to its opposite."
| PHYSICAL | 🔵🔵🔵🔵 |
| MENTAL | ⚪️⚪️⚪️⚪️ |
| FORCE | 🟡✖️⚪️⚪️ |
| GRACE | 🟡🟡🟡⚪️ |
| ATTACK | 🔴🔴🔴✖️ |
| DEFENSE | 🔴⚪️⚪️⚪️ |
🛠️ The Right Tool For The Job
Some actions require tools to even attempt. For example picking a lock cannot be done with your bare hands. Using an improvised tool, like some scrap wire would allow an attempt with a D12. If you have a tool designed for the action, like a set of lock picks, you will roll 2D6 instead!
During character creation, assign each player character one “favorite” piece of equipment. When this item is used appropriately, roll 3D6 then drop the lowest. This item is irreplaceable. You may find identical items in your game world, but they will not have the same mechanical benefits as your favorite item.
| EQUIPMENT | |||
| 1. | PHYSICAL | 🔵🔵⚪️⚪️ | __________ |
| 2. | MENTAL | 🔵🔵⚪️⚪️ | __________ |
| 3. | FORCE | 🟡🟡⚪️⚪️ | __________ |
| 4. | GRACE | 🟡🟡⚪️⚪️ | __________ |
| 5. | ATTACK | 🔴🔴⚪️⚪️ | __________ |
| 6. | DEFENSE | 🔴🔴⚪️⚪️ | __________ |
✨Magic Is Weird
🟦 PHYSICAL vs MENTAL
🟨 FORCE vs GRACE
🟥 ATTACK vs DEFENSE
Normal actions roll a D12 (or 2D6 if proper tools are used) against 🟦+🟨+🟥.
Magical actions roll a D8 (or 2D4 if proper tools are used) against 🟨+🟥 because magic is neither “physical” or “mental” …it’s weird
💔 Lasting Trauma
Remember when I said that “4” was the most difficulty points a stat could have? I lied. There is a secret fifth difficulty point!
| 1. | PHYSICAL | 🤍🔵🔵⚪️⚪️ |
| 2. | MENTAL | 🤍🔵🔵⚪️⚪️ |
| 3. | FORCE | 🤍🟡🟡⚪️⚪️ |
| 4. | GRACE | 🤍🟡🟡⚪️⚪️ |
| 5. | ATTACK | 🤍🔴🔴⚪️⚪️ |
| 6. | DEFENSE | 🤍🔴🔴⚪️⚪️ |
Characters can accrue up to six trauma. I haven’t decided exactly how the HP system works with this game yet, but I think the trauma system should be significant. Where difficulty points can be M&Ms you move around on a character sheet, trauma is drawn on with a Sharpie.

…Well that’s as much thought as I plan on putting into this game for now.
Check out rootr.ing